Skip to main content
vanagon.com
Checking account...
← vanagon.com home · Continue the discussion in the forum
Subject:Re: Copyright Free For All: Re: Vanagon "Journeys under difficult
From:bill
Date:Sun, 30 Mar 1997 16:07:59 -0700

If I were you, I'd be very careful with this.  Even assuming only financial
damage is covered, a contention that they *intended* to sell it again at
some undefined future point would make you liable.

Aside from that, there is the moral issue.  Stealing is not OK just because
you think you can get away with it.  Could I steal a candy bar from my
local convenience store and get away with it?  Probably.  Whether I get
away with it or not, it would still be wrong.

Copyright and patent laws protect "intellectual" property from theft.
There seems to be a growing idea that these are not important, but I guess
I'm just not locked into the material world well enough to believe that the
things I make with my hands are protected from theft, but the things I make
with my mind are free for the taking.

At 10:30 AM 3/30/97 -0600, you wrote:
>They cannot sue you for copyright infringement unless you cause financial
>damage to them. Since they are not offering this old document for sale, you
>can safely copy and redistribute it at will since you are not causing harm
>to a revenue stream that they are otherwise likely to get.
>
>Copyright only applies when there is financial damage. In the absence of
>demonstrated financial damage, they cannot collect. Everybody keep this in
>mind, and copy stuff as much as you like, especially stuff that is no longer
>for sale from the manufacturer. My guess is, it is probably safe to copy
>everything but the Bentley manuals.