

| Subject: | SMOG TEST failure |
| From: | John Goubeaux |
| Date: | Fri, 8 Feb 2008 12:07:39 -0800 |
Thanks to all who provided suggestions on how to pass the "Dreaded California Emissions Test" I was puzzled at how my HC values could be so high at idle, and pass at 2500 rpm, and that the Cat could still be the problem. I dredged up my values from 2 yrs ago, when I also failed on the first attempt, and passed after putting a new cat on, and I can see that the numbers reveal that I was basically in the same situation back then, and that replacing the cat resolved the problem. At least I have a good idea on how to pass this time around now. I guess one question is: "why did the NEW cat fail after 2 yrs" or did I "kill it" with a poorly tuned engine? (note i replaced the O2 sensor several months later) Has anyone else had bad results with the Emico converters? Does the warranty on these cover failure after 2 yrs? (i guess i should read the fine print) Below are the 3 sets of emission values. I hope this info, and discussion, might help other Californians, and those from other strict emission states keep their vanagons on the road! Values from 2 yrs ago (first attempt failed) ******************************************** rpm %CO2 %O2 HC(ppm) CO % RESULTS ____________________________________________ 871 8.4 8.5 637 .93 GROSS POLLUTER 2577 13.0 2.3 70 0.76 PASS **Replaced Catalytic Converter with EMICO Model Values from 2 yrs ago w/ New CAT (second attempt PASSED) **************************************************** rpm %CO2 %O2 HC(ppm) CO % RESULTS ____________________________________________ 861 14.9 .2 63 .01 PASS 2640 14.7 .4 37 .12 PASS Current Values: ***************************************************************** rpm %CO2 %O2 HC(ppm) CO % RESULTS ____________________________________________ 915 11.9 3.2 424 0.55 GROSS POLLUTER 2571 13.9 .5 66 0.55 PASS
Have something to add on this topic today? Revive this thread in the forum »